Well hey there, flavor scout!
Thanks for your feedback.
The second you hit submit, your pick got tossed straight into the mixing bowl with everyone else's and the flavors with the most love earn a spot in our Cookie Craving Club. So yes, your vote genuinely bakes into what's next.
Choose your plan
Monthly Subscription
Cookies on repeat, billed monthly. Cancel anytime after 3 months.
- A rotating Flavor of the Month
- Plus classic Original fan favorites
- Ships the first week of every month
- Skip, swap, or cancel after 3 months
- Free shipping on every box
Gift a Subscription
Prepaid for 3, 6, or 12 months. No auto-renew.
- Gooey of the Month, Original, or Classic Combo
- 6-pack or 12-pack sizes available
- Include a custom gift message
- Billed once upfront
- Ends when the term ends
Rosies Gooey Butter Cookies, a Midwest Original
Common questions
What do I get each month?
Each box has a limited-edition Flavor of the Month plus our classic originals. You can swap to all originals before the monthly cutoff.
When do cookies ship?
Cookie Craving Club boxes ship the first week of every month. New subscriptions begin with the next available monthly shipment, shown when you order, and you'll get tracking info the day it ships.
Can I cancel or skip?
Monthly subscriptions can be skipped, swapped, or cancelled after three months, before the monthly cutoff.
How do gift subscriptions work?
Gift subscriptions are prepaid for 3, 6, or 12 months. They end when the term ends. No auto-renew.
How fresh are the cookies?
Baked the day they ship, then heat-sealed. Good for two weeks at room temperature, or two months in the freezer. Thaw on the counter, or microwave 30 seconds for warm cookies.