Shipping was fast and the cookies arrived fresh and in perfect condition! Peach Pie knocked it out of the park this month! The flavor mix was great and I'm so glad peanut butter chocolate chip was included.
Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 4.1 / 5 from 35 reviews.
Always yummy! I love the variety and thankfully even with moving to a new address the cookies have followed me. Boxes seem to do a decent job of keeping everything fresh and delicious too
We loved your cookies when we were traveling to Indiana. I signed up for the cookie club, it sounded like a fun idea. The cookies arrive fresh and neatly packaged. I don’t love that there have been 2 originals in the packages. I wish we could have options to select what we like. Some of the flavors have been amazing and some I didn’t care for and would not have chosen. I also wish it could include your shortbread cookies, which are amazing! This last batch had a pumpkin cookie which was REALLY gooey- seemed almost raw. Some of the others have seemed a little too gooey at times as well. I understand this is a new program for you and you might still be working out the details. I am going to give it one more month, but I may end up not moving forward as it is too many gooey butter cookies in a month for us! The cookies are really good overall- I just wish we could select flavors and have options for the shortbread cookies. Thank you! Linnae Satterlee
Just not a fan of the cookies. They crumble from the outside and the gooey part is too raw for my tastes. Sorry.
The cookies are awesome like they all have been so far!!!
The cookies arrived pretty smashed and doughy this time around. I've decided to cancel our subscription.
I decided to cancel our subscription after two deliveries that aren’t as good as what I can buy in the store. We live about 15 minutes from Noblesville Rosie’s but I thought it would be fun for the kids and I to receive these packages in the mail. Unfortunately, the last two shipments have had cookies that are stale around the edges and crumbly dry.
I enjoy getting my cookies each month because they are always delicious and it is a bit of a surprise what I'll receive. It's fun to have guests over and tell them we will be having Rosie's Gooey Butter Cookies for dessert... their eyes light up and when they realize we can taste a number of different flavors at the same time, it's priceless!
Cinnamon roll was my favorite.
The pumpkin and cinnamon roll were great! Cookies seemed fresher this month. Liked the two special flavors in box. Maybe always ship on first Monday or Tuesday of month so shipment arrives before weekend. If ship too late in week they don’t make it until The next week. We love getting them each month. Thanks
Loved how this box did not have the chocolate and instead had cinnamon roll! That was such a pleasant surprise!
Your cookies so soft, gooey, delicious perfection! The best cookies ever!! 😊😋
They were thinner and drier than the ones I have purchased in store
The cookies were tasty. Unfortunately, one was smashed due to shipping. Several of the flavors were identical to last month’s box so while they were, of course, delicious, that was a bit disappointing. QC on the caramel apple was off, only one tiny piece of apple in the entire cookie.
Service delivery time cost is very good. But the cookies are a bit too gooey for me. It’s like eating raw batter. The first one I ever had was peanut butter choc chip and it was the best cookie I ever had. I just don’t remember it being this gooey and sweet.
This shipment was not as fresh as the first. We live 15 minutes or less from Rosie’s Noblesville so it was surprising to find the traditional cookies were stale and crumbly.
I feel like these cookies are too gooey as compared to the stores. I like them a bit "harder/crisper" than what I am getting shipped to me.
The cookies are delicious. They do have a crumbly outer layer that you don’t get if you purchase them from the store but it doesn’t distract from the overall. I’m not sure what could be causing it other than it did take 6 days to travel to Kokomo which is a distance of under 50 miles from the shipping point so they are sitting somewhere. I can see sitting one overnight but not 5.
We received the cookies yesterday, 09/15 and were very disappointed. All of the cookies were crusty and old. Last month our cookies were gooey and delicious but this month their texture was far from fresh.
These cookies are so soft and delicious!! Each flavor gets better and better 😋
Maybe a bit too gooey for my liking. Too underbaked for me.
We love your cookies
All the cookies that came in the box were delicious!!
I loved the packaging. It felt like a special occasion when I unboxed my cookies! I received six delicious Gooey Butter Cookies: two Original, two Peach, one Chocolate, and one Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip. I did need to heat the cookies up to return them to their gooey-deliciousness.
I was so impressed with my first monthly cookie club box. The presentation was amazing and the cookies even better. I can't wait for next box!
Cutest packaging and delicious cookies!!
The cookies were just okay. Not like getting them fresh at your restaurants. I also thought they were smaller than the ones in store and flatter. It was a nice “taste of home” though.
Cookies are so good. I hope they "fan favorites" rotate each month
I really like the peanut butter chocolate chip and the chocolate ones but the butter cookies was like eating cookie dough. Like they were not cooked completely. Not like what I had at Rosie’s Place. However they were boxed beautifully and fresh. It would be nice if I could pick the cookies I wanted
Best cookies ever! Can’t wait for the next month’s delivery.
The chocolate was fantastic! The peanut butter chocolate chip was very good. Was not a fan of the peach pie cookies. One of the traditional gooey butter cookies was somewhat stale. It basically crumbled up when pulled apart/bitten into. The other traditional tasted good. All cookies were eaten within a week of receiving. The packaging is top notch. The enclosures were well done (there is a typo on one insert sorry can’t remember which one) and creative. Loved the Founder’s Club sticker.
Really beautiful packaging! I would definitely send to those out of town. However....the cookies themselves are decidedly different from the fresh ones you get at Rosies, and we would rather just go pick some up.
I enjoy having the assortment each month as well as the special flavor of the month.
Nicely packaged and so yummy!
Delicious! OG gooy was the fav!